I know there’s a lot of controversy going around Driscoll’s new book.
* I’ve been getting a lot of heat for this. I’m apologize if I sinned against anyone in any way or form through this post. If I am not Christlike at all in this post, then I ask for your forgiveness. Please notify me asap if I have. I have stated multiple times for everyone to decide and discern for yourself using the Word of God. I tried my best to inform my readers and to speak the truth in love. (Ephesians 4:15) My opinion is simply that I personally find no shame in not reading the (whole) book but if you want to read it and it benefits you, then be discerning about it. Thanks for taking the time to read this and God bless!
Should I read Real Marriage?
Background info: I’m a member of Mars Hill Church. I’ve been listening to Mark Driscoll since I was 16 and he’s one of my favorite preachers. However, it is important to be very discerning of your leaders. I’m quite familiar with how Driscoll writes as I have read many of his books and read his blog often. I thoroughly enjoy Driscoll’s teachings and writings but I am still reluctant and hesitant to endorse Real Marriage.
However, just because Driscoll says something does not mean it’s right. Just because this book is number 1 on Amazon does not mean that you have to agree with everything he says. He is a sinner (as am I) and sinners make mistakes.
I also made it a point to read Driscoll’s own Q&A with Christianity Today, his article in The Washington Post as well as his current blog posts. This way, I would have a balanced, unbiased view on both sides. Now taking some of my background in mind, here we go:
The highlight of what the Driscolls teach on marriage is probably the importance of friendship and their honesty. I also appreciate that he does have the boldness to talk about such topics and is being real about it. I also kind of like the controversy that’s going on since people are not just mindlessly agreeing with everything. They’re actually speaking up with what they like or dislike, agree or disagree, and the pros and cons. (most of the time using the Bible) I like listening to the variety of different opinions regarding this book. I also find it quite interesting that so many people are reading this. Understandably, the Driscoll’s have a huge platform and are fairly well known even in the secular world.
Challies writes, “There are also factual errors, like when the Driscolls state that Solomon was the child born of David and Bathsheba’s adultery (when, in fact, that child died and Solomon was born later)” Sorry to burst anyone’s bubble, but I am shocked about this error. (2 Samuel 12:14-31) It probably shocked me more than the other things he’s written… I’m surprised the editors and publishers didn’t catch this either as the Bible clearly states that the child died. Eek! That credibility part kind of simmered down just a tad… Let’s go to the Bible:
Then David comforted his wife, Bathsheba, and went in to her and lay with her, and she bore a son, and he called his name Solomon. And the LORD loved him - 2 Samuel 12:24
In Jerusalem David took more wives and became the father of more sons and daughters.These are the names of the children born to him there: Shammua, Shobab, Nathan, Solomon- 1 Chronicles 14:3-4
Not only is this an error but multiple reviewers have said that there is a huge misunderstanding of Ephesians 5 as well as 1 Corinthians 6:12 being taken out of context. Most of these reviews are by solid Reformed theologians I look up to as they back up their positions with Scripture. Another thing I noticed is the problem with the grid and the lack of Driscoll mentioning the motives of the heart (saying that plastic surgery is okay for people to feel more attractive to their spouses) The Bible says “For you formed my inward parts; you knitted me together in my mother’s womb. I praise you, for I am fearfully and wonderfully made. Wonderful are your works; my soul knows it very well,” (Psalm 139:13-14 ESV).”What is the motive of this? Does it bring glory to God?
“This relates to a story you tell about a time Grace had her long hair cut and got a “short, mommish haircut.” Mark, you disliked the cut and write that Grace “had put a mom’s need for convenience before being a wife.” I understand that Driscoll is a total manly “dude’s dude” but he puts emphasis on outward appearance. I want to know where the emphasis on inner beauty (1 Peter 3:3-4) or the highly praised Proverbs 31 woman or mentioning a woman after God’s own heart. Does this bring glory to God? Is there an emphasis on the gospel message the uniting marriage?
I want to make this very clear. I don’t want anyone to make their opinion based off mine.
- I want you all to be Bereans.
- Read the Bible and search out Scripture.
- I encourage you to back up your opinions with The Word of God.
- Ask yourself thought provoking questions.
- Read it with discernment.
- Remember there is the good and bad in almost every book.
I have compiled a list of 10 reviews/resources that I found to be helpful (both yay and nay)
Women of God magazine: http://www.wogmagazine.com/2012/01/book-review-real-marriage/
Tim Challies (there are 3 parts, I just included the first one): http://www.challies.com/book-reviews/book-review-real-marriage
The Gospel Coalition: http://thegospelcoalition.org/book-reviews/review/real_marriage
9 Reasons Real Marriage is for Singles: http://pastormark.tv/2012/01/04/9-reasons-real-marriage-is-for-singles
Pastor Mark’s blog (appropriate for children) http://pastormark.tv/2012/01/11/is-real-marriage-appropriate-for-kids
I have put enormous thought and consideration (months before the book was published) in deciding to read if this book would be a beneficial and edifying read (I have read the first chapter though just to get a glimpse of it). I have asked a wide variety of people married and single from my church. I have contemplated both sides of the argument. I’m cautious of every book and I’m really not trying to criticize Driscoll. If it was a different author, I would still approach the book in the same manner. With this in mind, I would caution all of my followers to be discerning of every book. His singleness, dating, and marriage series has been very helpful to me. His various ministries have also been a blessing to my life. (Resurgence, music, blogs, books, videos, sermons, Elephant Room, Gospel Coalition, etc) I highly admire his way of engaging church, culture, and community. In addition, I like how he tells boys to man up and how to treat women. As I said earlier, I thoroughly enjoy Driscoll’s other teachings and writings.
Personally, as someone who has never had marriage nor sex, I find no shame in deciding not to read the whole book. I don’t know if it’s entirely necessary since I have to listen to the sermon series anyways. However, I’ve heard wonderful 5 star reviews of The Meaning of Marriage by Keller. I’ve started to read a bit of it and I would say it is a gospel saturated read. Scripture has a very high view on marriage and as God’s children we should too. Although I am still unsure about Real Marriage, I will let you know asap if anything changes. My opinion is definitely the minority and the unpopular one but I still love you all dearly. If you do decide to read it and enjoy it, remember that we are all family in Christ and minor issues like this should not divide the church or our love and service for one another :)
- hamiltonok4 likes this
- csleeper likes this
- angdiarynahindinabubulok likes this
- repeater75 reblogged this from jasminecrystal and added:
- repeater75 said: Awesome post, Jasmine! Lots of caring thought went into this. Your heart really feels to me like it is in the right place throughout.
- jamescabbagechen reblogged this from jasminecrystal
- jamescabbagechen likes this
- overeffect said: I’m going to his real marriage tour with a few friends when he comes to SD. Was never going buy the book unless he blew my mind…which he might who knows. But I’m mostly attending to have dialogue on the subject, and maybe relate it to my life
- grace-faith-andlongboards likes this
- jasminecrystal posted this